3

Background:
The Welsh Duo Lingo course was designed in two parts: the "flash cards" (the things you do in the app) and the accompanying course notes.

Unfortunately the notes were never available inside the app, so many discussions on the flash cards point to an address where a more thorough explanation of the grammar can be found.
Then, to make things worse, that link rotted, so anyone taking the Welsh Duo course is effectively learning blind.

How to restore that guidance is a separate issue, but I'm trying to persevere with what I can piece together from elsewhere (the content for about 3 of the 80+ units has been preserved here). I understand a few of the contexts where a mutation is 'triggered' in Welsh, but then a flash card came up with two mutations, neither of which I understand, which leads to my question:

Unexplained mutations
Wnaethoch chi bryd o fwyd ddydd Sadwrn?

Why does 'pryd' mutate to 'bryd' and 'dydd' mutate to 'ddydd' in this sentence?

For ddydd, my best guess is that the mutation marks that it is showing when something happened (like using the proposition 'on' in English), but for bryd I'm really not sure. Is it because it's the object of the past-tense sentence? Is it simply because it follows the word 'chi'? I cannot easily apply any of the rules found here.

Perhaps the course will one day be 'fixed' and access to the notes will be restored, but hopefully this question remains self-contained and relevant enough to stand on its own.

Additional: This question is about learning the Welsh language rather than language learning in general. I couldn't find a Welsh-specific stack exchange, but if there is one, and this question would fit better there, please feel free to move it! I don't have enough reputation to add/create a welsh or welsh-language tag.

2 Answers 2

1

There are actually several mutations here in this question:

Did you make a meal on Saturday?

The first word:

gwnaethoch

This mutates in the 'soft' form (by losing the 'g') to wnaethoch, as it is at the start of a question. Without the mutation, this would be a statement:
You made a meal on Saturday.

In my continued learning, I have since found out why the next mutation happens:

bryd o fwyd

This is explained in this YouTube video:

There's always a soft mutation after the initial part of a past tense [clause]

I interpret this to mean this will happen after the subject.
In the example given, wnaethoch is the verb and chi is the subject, so whatever comes after chi takes its soft mutation. See the full linked video for more examples with subjects other than chi.

I've still not worked out why we have a mutation for Saturday:

ddydd Sadwrn

I will return and update this answer if I find out.

0
  1. References to time in sentences always undergo soft mutation.

  2. If the object of the sentence directly follows the subject, the object undergoes soft mutation. It doesn't have anything specifically to do with tense, but it is common to have an object directly following the compact form of the verb. (Note that 'compact' might not be the best English translation.) These are forms not involving 'bod'.

    • Gwnaethoch chi bryd
    • Roeddech chi'n gwneud pryd
  3. Compare:

    • Gwnaethoch chi
    • Wnaethoch chi?
    • Wnaethoch chi ddim

    That is, the question and negation mutate. They do this because there are words there which are implicit in spoken and informal written Welsh, but are explicit in the formal written language.

It is actually a bit more complex than this.

New contributor
cfr is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering. Check out our Code of Conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.