4

This issue arises over and over:

In Mandarin Chinese, I often read a paragraph aloud, concentrating on pronunciation. I've studied all (or almost all) the words, and know what they mean individually. I'll pat myself on the back and think to myself: "Nailed it! Your Chinese is getting better!"

Then someone asks me "so, what does it say?" And frustratingly, often I'll be forced to reply "I have no idea." Perhaps I might be able to say something superficial.

The problem is that locally I understand everything, but after proceeding to the subsequent words, or the next sentence, I just forget the previous material. I could tell you what each sentence in the paragraph means after reading it, but not what the paragraph itself means.

Question: How can I overcome the problem of knowing all the words, but missing the overall meaning?

2

There are various strategies that might help:

  1. Pre-reading strategies: Right now, it seems you begin by focusing on the individual items and try to understand these first; this is a bottom-up approach. Before you begin this, you can try a top-down approach to give a general idea of what the text will be about:
  • Read through the title, subtitles, and any pictures/diagrams etc., and then actively guess the main contents.
  • Scan through the contents quickly, try to focus on keywords, and guess the main contents; then begin reading each sentence more carefully.
  1. Sentence-by-sentence review:
    After each sentence you read, speak out loud (or in your head) and say the main meaning of the sentence. If a sentence is too long, you could do it phrase-by-phrase. By making concrete what you know regularly, you'll stimulate your memory, allowing you to remember the contents better at the end of reading the passage.

  2. Post-reading Practice summarizing the main contents after reading a passage. If possible, do it in Chinese, and try to do so without looking at it while you summarize.

2

I have actually found this is really related to reading speed/ease for me. Volume of reading is what got me over this hump. Try and read english really slow where you look at a word and then stop and read the next word. It is actually quite hard to understand and follow complex sentences when you don't get them all in one chunk.

I used to struggle with this (and still do for more complex chinese passages) because the mental effort of recalling the word or grammar principle meant I had forgotten the previous bit. As my reading volume and speed improved I found I could parse more complex bits easier. Wasn't related to learning new words so much as just being comfortable enough with the words I knew that I didn't have to think about them.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.